Google

WWW ISOU




Like ISOU? Make a Donation!


Connect
View David Anderson's profile on LinkedIn
Categories
Recent Entries
 

« Full Tilt Mode on Work! | Main | Life in Costa Rica »

October 25, 2005
Grim Milestone Reached... 2,000 US Dead in Iraq

So the moment has arrived after days of speculation and drum beating on both sides of the political spectrum. Based on the amount of spin the last couple of days, I am sure this is going to get major media play. 2,000th American Dead in Iraq! But when it all comes down to it, that will simply be simplifying an issue that most Americans simply don't want to deal with... The question of whether invading Iraq was worth even ONE American life?

BAGHDAD, Iraq -- The U.S. military has announced the death of an American soldier who was wounded in Iraq.

That brings the U.S. death toll to 2,000.

The toll compiled by The Associated Press reached 2,000 with the death of an Army sergeant who was wounded by a roadside bomb north of Baghdad. He died last weekend in Texas.

Staff Sgt. George Alexander of Killeen, Texas, was wounded last week in Samarra, north of Baghdad. He was based at Fort Benning in Georgia.

Earlier Tuesday, President George W. Bush warned the nation to brace for an even higher casualty count, saying there's more work ahead in Iraq before the job is done.

But the first U.S. service member to die in the Iraq war is just as important as the 2,000th. A U.S. military spokesman said that is why the military does not consider the death of the 2,000th American in Iraq a milestone.

And the chief spokesman for the American-led coalition force is asking reporters not to treat it as a milestone, either.

The military earlier Tuesday announced the deaths of two Marines killed last week in Baghdad. Their deaths raised to 1,999 the number of members of the U.S. military killed since the Iraq war started in March of 2003. This latest death makes the toll hit 2,000.

But in an e-mail, military spokesman Steve Boylan spoke of what he calls the "daily milestones" in the war against terrorism, which he said are rarely covered. Those include the struggles faced by families of soldiers serving for a year or more. and the Iraqis who've fought along with U.S. forces, making themselves daily targets for militant attacks.

As for the 2,000 death, Boylan calls that an "artificial mark on the wall."

I have mixed emotions about the numbers game. I would tend to agree that the first soldier killed is just as important as the 2,000th. I would also tend to agree that it is but one statistic among many sad statistics of this war. Discounting the thousands of Iraqi's dead, or the victims of terrorist atrocities in Iraq since the war started is a slap in the face of those sacrifices.

Nor is it possible to look at the state of the war in Iraq today and to imagine 2,000 being anywhere near the finaly death tally for American troops. We are a society obsessed with numbers and no doubt when the number of U.S. killed surpasses that of those who died on 9/11, there will be other comparisons.


102303_dead.jpgI had a long, (too long) conversation with a conservative friend of mine today about the war, and I realized during that discussion how fruitless it is to even have a discussion on the subject.

Those who believe this war was just, will continue to do so no matter what. Those who think we should bring our troops home regardless of the eventual outcome in Iraq, will likewise continue to feel that way. Those like me....

I feel that the war was wrong, possibly illegal and almost certainly based on lies, but believe we need to, "fix what we broke," and will more than likely continue to believe that way.

None of it matters to the dead... And none of it will bring them back...

Posted by David A at October 25, 2005 02:51 PM
Filed Under Iraq | 628 Words
Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.grupo-utopia.com/blog/mt/mt-tb.cgi/917

Comments

However grimly unfortunate for any of my comrades or myself to pay the ultimate price, it is nothing compared to past conflicts. At the current rate it would take us 50 years to reach the KIA totals of WW2. And we lost nearly 10 thousand soldiers fighting the "Wolf Brigades" (insurgents) in Germany after WW 2. We fought them untill the 50's. Those of us who have freedom have no comprehension of it's value. Talk to an Iraqi man, ask him how he feels about us giving them freedom. Sure some Iraqi's disagree about us being there, but look at half the crap we disagree with each other in our own country. I have seen the looks of hope in Iraqi faces, I have even seen them sorrow at our own losses. I know they crave freedom and a future free from tyranny. And I for one, will not let us going there be for nothing. The blood of my brothers lies in the very ground of Iraq. And if we pulled out like the chickenshit's the left wants us to be then I will go back as a contracter and fight for my fellow soldiers sacrifice.

Posted by: Soldier at October 26, 2005 07:55 AM

any deaths (never mind 2,000) - under any circumstances are obviously tragic but some iraqis are truly appreciative of the sacrifices that have been made on their behalf - i speak mainly from the kurdish standpoint. There has just been an advertising release in the US which is thanking the coalition for their help in liberating them from oppresion - have a look at www.theotheriraq.com. Considering that not a single coalition soldier has lost their life in this present conflict in the KRG controlled area it is all the more positive - but then who is interested in good news??? I d be interested to hear anyone's comments.

Posted by: Blossom Bates at November 9, 2005 07:40 AM

Post a comment

Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


Remember me?

Subscribe to this comment thread.


 
Finalist For the Third Straight Year!
2006finalist170bn0.gif

Second Place! - Latin America, Caribbean and South America!



2005 Weblog Awards Finalist!
wa_finalist150.jpg


2004 Weblog Awards Finalist!
200wde_2004WeblogAwds_Fnl1.jpg


Get the Best for your Ad Dollar


Get the Best Bang for your Buck!


advertise_liberally.gif


Navigation
scan00038fz.jpg
Search
Technorati search
Meta
Movable Type 3.2
Logo by Zencomix
Template by Rogue
Stats